Friday 16 January 2015

House Sparrow x Spanish Sparrow

possible House Sparrow x Spanish Sparrow hybrid or House Sparrow x Eurasian Tree Sparrow hybrid or Italian Sparrow, Northrepps (Norfolk, UK), 18th August 2013 - copyright Dave Appleton
(photo ID: 1776)

When this curious bird was found the possibility that it was an Italian Sparrow was mooted.  Indeed it has been submitted as such but the British Birds Rarities Committee have effectively pended the record until taxonomy or identification criteria are resolved (British Birds 108: 630).  A 'classic' Italian Sparrow should not have any grey in the crown but it seems that birds in the north of the range (presumably where introgression with House Sparrow still occurs?) may have some grey in the crown. 

In the photo above it looks as though it has a hint of a dark spot at the lower back of the cheeks, which would strongly suggest Eurasian Tree Sparrow involvement.  I didn't think this was a real plumage feature though - just the way the feathers were lying.  Indeed the absence of a dark spot in the cheeks was one reason I doubted what some people eventually concluded, which is that it was a House Sparrow x Eurasian Tree Sparrow hybrid.  Most House Sparrow x Eurasian Tree Sparrows I've seen photos of have had at least a small dark spot in the cheeks (see also our House Sparrow x Eurasian Tree Sparrow page).

Another reason to doubt that was the almost complete absence of grey in the crown.  There were a few spots of grey in the forecrown - at the time we thought at least some of these were effects of moult - feather bases being visible where feathers were missing or loose - but as they appear in other photos taken later on including in 2014 when it reappeared briefly, they must have been a real plumage feature after all.  Most House Sparrow x Eurasian Tree Sparrow hybrids have more grey in the crown than this.

The bill was large, possibly suggesting Spanish/Italian Sparrow involvement and there were none of the buffy tones to the body that are often displayed by House Sparrow x Eurasian Tree Sparrow hybrids (actually some other poeple's photos do seem to show such tones, but not in all frames and covering a different area in different frames - I think those images may be showing the bird after it had been bathing in dust - I have seen House Sparrows with a similar effect from bathing in dust).  I wondered if it might instead by a House Sparrow x Spanish Sparrow hybrid.  It looks a lot like an Italian Sparrow and Italian Sparrows are meant to be the product of hybridisation between House Sparrows and Spanish Sparrows, so this does seem a realistic possibility.  A few Spanish Sparrows have turned up in the UK and spent time - even whole summers - with House Sparrows.  None have been known to produce hybrids but how many others have been overlooked or not even seen - especially if they were females?  It doesn't seem a terribly implausible explanation.

To progress this further I suspect we will need to get better knowledge of the extent of variation in House Sparrow x Eurasian Tree Sparrow hybrids and also a better understanding of what first-generation House Sparrow x Spanish Sparrow hybrids look like, and of course the range of variation in Italian Sparrow.

possible House Sparrow x Spanish Sparrow hybrid or House Sparrow x Eurasian Tree Sparrow hybrid or Italian Sparrow (same bird as in photo ID 1776 above), Northrepps (Norfolk, UK), 18th August 2013 - copyright Dave Appleton
(photo IDs: 1777-1779)

My original analysis of this bird, along with extra photos, can be found here.  More images of this bird from other photographers and on other dates appear here and here.

Note that Italian Sparrow taxon is now considered to be a result of hybrid speciation.  A population of House Sparrow x Spanish Sparrow hybrids have eventually become stabilised and more-or-less reproductively isolated from their ancestor taxa.

House Sparrow Passer domesticus
Italian Sparrow Passer italiae
Spanish Sparrow Passer hispaniolensis
Eurasian Tree Sparrow Passer montanus

1 comment:

  1. We currently have a very similar bird to this in Bristol. It's been at least since last year, but only been widely known about since a pic of it was posted on the avon birds website on 30thof March, here:-
    The bird's favoured haunts were quickly located, But in spite of a post on Avon Birds from Keith Vinicombe pointing out the possibility of it being an Italian Sparrow, and in spite of it being extremely easy to see on a public road, and in spite of frequent updates on it's continual presence, it appears to have attracted almost zero interest from local birders. I'm not a ringer, but I would imagine it could probably be trapped fairly easily in the garage alley along Huyton Rd, where it has been coming down to scattered food. There are now some more recent images of it, and it still retains some grey in the crown, but some has worn off since the images from March and April on the avon birds website. It differs from your bird in not having such a swollen bill, and not having any suggestion at all of the dark cheek mark you mention. My thoughts are that it surely must be either an Italian Sparrow, or a hybrid between an Italian or Spanish Sparrow and a House Sparrow, unless House Sparrows are capable of somehow displaying this phenotype on occasion. Interesting stuff's just amusing how little interest it's attracted. I guess the Devon bird hasn't helped with that! Either way, it's been a nice start to my mornings seeing it on my way to work :)

    Larry Sweetland